Home »
Strengthening or weakening liquidity standards?
strengthening-or-weakening-liquidity-standards
The UK financial services regulator, the Financial Services Authority (FSA) has been consulting with banks and financial market participants on its response to the so-called liquidity crisis.
Boasting the memorable title of CP08/22:Strengthening Liquidity Standards, the FSA consultation paper talks about "high-level" requirements for banks to maintain "adequate" liquidity at all times without relying on other parts of the group.
The consultation paper also mentions the need for adequate systems and controls for liquidity management; quantitative standards for liquidity; standards around quality and quantity of liquid assets and the requirement for a liquidity buffer of "high quality unencumbered assets"; as well as data pertaining to a "firm-specific" and "market-wide view" of liquidity risk.
It sounds reminiscent of Basel II in that the consultation paper talks about qualitative and quantitative standards. I would not be surprised if the FSA's consultation paper gives rise to a cottage industry of conferences, vendor solutions and consultants, all eager to plug their FSA- friendly liquidity risk management expertise.
While the FSA proposes that it will conduct a supervisory liquidity review of each firm, alarm bells start ringing when one reads that the FSA is still pursuing a "high-level" principles-based approach to regulation.
In light of recent market events, which clearly demonstrate that the banks themselves and the regulators got it so horribly wrong, one has to question whether a wholly principles-based approach to regulation works. The FSA also mentions that responsibility for liquidity risk lies with the banks themselves, not the central banks or regulators, but haven't we seen the devastating consequences of what happens when banks are left to their own devices?
Some risk management consultants I have spoken to have also expressed misgivings about the consultation paper (CP08/24) that the FSA published on stress and scenario testing back in December 2008.
The FSA proposes to introduce a "reverse-stress test" requirement for banks, building societies, investment firms and insurers, requiring firms to consider "the scenarios most likely to cause their current business model to become "unviable".
Sounds great in theory, but as one risk management consultant pointed out to me, the banking industry and the FSA are not "up to speed" on scenario planning, unlike the oil and aerospace industries which have 40 years of experience. So what chances do we have of the banks and the FSA, who are part of the problem, getting it right?
The consultant said the current risk management strategies banks use such as Value at Risk (VaR) were no good at predicting extreme events. Using the example of a plastic ruler being bent, the consultant said while mathematics could calculate how much the ruler would bend, it could not predict at which point it would snap. "[The collapse of] Lehman Brothers was like the ruler snapping," he said. Yet, standard risk models failed to predict the point at which Lehman's would snap, let alone the consequences that ensued.
While placing more emphasis on stress testing and scenario planning in terms of contemplating a myriad of "what if" scenarios may help firms better anticipate the unexpected, the consultant said that the problem with the FSA's approach is that it was taking the standard risk models (how much the ruler is bending) and applying them to something that only matters when the ruler snaps.
Money-market funds are under threat from touted SEC reforms
An ICD client survey indicates that money-market funds could lose more than USD 700 billion with dire consequences for investment in...Read More >>
Financial transaction tax will lead to a shift of business away from funds in Europe
EFAMA says the EC and the public have underestimated the detrimental impact of a transaction tax on savings by retail and institutional...Read More >>
Vista Equity Partners launches rival bid for Misys
Banking and risk management software provider Misys was due to merge with core banking software provider, Temenos, but Vista Equity's bid...Read More >>
Corporate treasury professionals join the Basel-bashing bandwagon
According to a recent survey by EuroFinance, approximately 60% of Western European corporate treasury professionals believe Basel III will...Read More >>
Banking at a crossroads
Jayan Dhru, global head of Financial Institution Ratings, Standard and Poor's, explains its new criteria for rating banks, which places...
Read More >>
German and Spanish banks face the biggest capital shortfalls, following latest stress tests
German banks' total capital shortfall is now in the region of EUR 13 billion, according to the European Banking Authority's latest...Read More >>
Firms are moving away from a "box ticking" mentality when it comes to risk technology
Chartis's RiskTech 100 highlights a revolution in the financial services industry as finance and risk converge. Banks are tipped to spend...Read More >>
Cybersecurity threat could bring down banks
US and European banks fear that a cyberattack could diminish their economic viability. Dealing with such attacks costs an average USD 5.9...Read More >>
Basel Committee makes minor trade finance concessions
Concessions designed to minimise negative impacts in low-income countries but the much-maligned leverage ratio will still apply to trade...Read More >>
Eurozone crisis weighs on UK corporate growth
Corporates say the European Financial Stability Facility is unlikely to solve investor nervousness in Europe's sovereign debt markets.
Read More >>
SEPA end date would send a strong political message and increase confidence in the euro
SIA Expo in Milan calls for SEPA end date to be finalised without delay, however, the European Commission says substantial challenges...
Read More >>
Erste Group takes balance sheet measures as sovereign debt crisis continues to weigh on European banks
Erste Group reduced its sovereign exposure with asset disposals and will refocus its Hungarian operations in light of "unprecedented"...Read More >>
RBS among 12 UK financial institutions downgraded by Moody's
Ratings agency says the UK government is likely to continue to support "systemically-important" financial institutions, however it will be...Read More >>
Market volatility sees Deutsche Bank issue a revised outlook for 2011
Bank announces 500 jobs to go as volumes and revenues in its Corporate Banking & Securities Corporate Division decline, however, Global...Read More >>
Follow the money
The Sibos conference in Toronto closed with the focus on emerging markets; for the economic power of the old world is moving east to Asia...
Read More >>
Concerns continue to mount about the eurozone, and USD liquidity, but could the renminbi be the answer?
Behind the scenes at this year's Sibos conference in Toronto, regulation is taking a back seat to concerns around the future of the...
Read More >>
Never ending story
.jpg?width=100)
John Gubert, our guest blogger at Sibos, was at yesterday's Big Issue Debate. The topic was the financial transaction infrastructure, and...
Read More >>
Talk of business exits not expansion
Headcount and discretionary spend are likely to be impacted by the less than optimistic outlook for custodian banks' returns in the next 12...
Read More >>
Sibos Toronto - No 'Big Bang' kick-off
Guest blogger, Chris Pickles, head of industry initiatives, BT, says day one of the Sibos conference in Toronto has not resulted in any new...
Read More >>
SWIFT is the new barometer for global economic activity
Forget the Dow Jones' stock indexes, it is the Global SWIFT Index which is the new barometer for global economic growth.
Sibos...
Read More >>
Ringfencing could force banks to move to shared service model
Mark Jenkinson, Capco Partner, UK banking team, says Vickers' ringfencing proposals for UK banks could lead to a shared service model where...
Read More >>
Ringfencing will not safeguard against future failures
Mixed reactions to Vickers Independent Commission on Banking report into ringfencing banks' retail operations, with some saying it will...
Read More >>
LSE revives its bid for LCH.Clearnet
The London Stock Exchange submits second bid for majority stake in LCH.Clearnet as it looks to consolidate its clearing business in...Read More >>
SEPA takes a back seat as VocaLink realigns its priorities
VocaLink announces phased withdrawal of its Euro CSM and SEPA value-added services as it refocuses its global strategy on real-time...Read More >>
A brave new world without AAAs
Citi's Global Economics Team warns of further sovereign downgrades, with France thought to be the next G7 country at risk of losing its AAA...
Read More >>
Italy more likely to default than Spain
The Centre for Economics and Business Research says that Spain has less of a debt burden than Italy and that it could export its way out of...Read More >>
Testing times
On the eve of bank stress tests by the EBA, Clive Stainton, head of Risk at Rule Financial, says that the FSA has been caught napping and...
Read More >>
Is the euro doomed?
A Greek default does not necessarily spell the end of the euro, but most believe the eurozone is unlikely to survive in its current form.Read More >>
Focus in sovereign debt crisis shifts to Spain and Italy
Greece is just a "sideshow", the real issue is whether Italy and Spain can remain in the eurozone.
Read More >>
Portugal and Ireland fail to enact much-needed reforms
Institutional incentives in the eurozone were to blame for fiscal irresponsibility in Portugal and Ireland, says IEA.
Read More >>
EuroFinance Miami: European sovereign debt crisis far from over
Treasurers and banks expect Greece will default and the future of the eurozone in its current form remains in doubt.
Read More >>
Middle East unrest puts spotlight on insurance
As turbulence in the Arab world continues, Anthony Palmer, deputy chairman, BPL Global, highlights the deficiencies in investors' standard...
Read More >>
Inflation, interest rate rises and fiscal squeeze weighs on CFOs less optimistic outlook
Deloitte CFO survey suggests UK CFOs' optimism has fallen to its lowest level in two years, however, companies are seeking growth...
Read More >>
Banks safer under Basel III, but profits could fall by a third
Basel III will force banks to widen margins and increase the cost of lending, says financial training company.
Read More >>
Editor's opinion: Too big to fail?
Does "too big to fail" have any place in a market economy? The Governor of the Bank of England doesn't think so but cash management...
Read More >>
Bank of America to appoint head of Global Treasury Solutions
Paul Simpson is reportedly leaving Citi to take up the new position at Bank of America Merrill Lynch as it emphasizes the importance of GTS...Read More >>
Banks must overcome their fear of lending
A number of UK banks report increased lending to SMEs in 2010 and government initiatives are underway to increase credit availability to...
Read More >>
Cash hoarding by corporates may be coming to an end
Fitch Ratings survey of European fixed income investors predicts companies will loosen their "purse strings" and spend cash on M&A,...
Read More >>
Banks over analyse innovation opportunities in payments
Second report from The Global Innovation Jury highlights how traditional payment organisations stifle innovation in favour of legacy...
Read More >>
Twitter in the trading room
.jpg?width=100)
Financial-i columnist, Gerald Ashley, says Twitter is radically transforming the way market and financial news is distributed. But...
Read More >>
The Bribery Act: should I wait?
Sian Herbert, a partner in PwC's forensic services practice says delays to the implementation of the UK's Bribery Act is a "double-edged"...
Read More >>
Fortress Europe is not the answer
Financial Secretary to the UK Treasury, Marc Hoban, lay down the gauntlet to the European Commission to get the MiFID Review right,...
Read More >>
Editor's comment: Breaking up the banks - who will pay?
The politicians need to think carefully before "breaking up the banks". If they have their way the face of banking will be unrecognisable...
Read More >>
Financial-i pays tribute to supply chain finance luminary, Sarah Jones
Sarah Jones, head of strategic business development at order-to-pay software provider, Bottomline Technologies, and a pioneer when it comes...
Read More >>
One in five chance that the euro will survive in its current form, says Cebr report
Research report says consumer spending cuts of 15% or more, greater than those endured by UK consumers during World War II, need to happen...
Read More >>
US Treasury sells remaining shares in Citi
Government says it will make a profit of at least $12 billion on the sale of its remaining shares in Citi, finally freeing the Wall Street...Read More >>
Video interview: Basel III will not kill trade finance
.jpg?width=100)
Tan Kah Chye says the Basel Committee is not discriminating against trade finance with its proposed Basel III capital requirements,...
Read More >>
Time for sorting out mechanisms for winding up distressed banks, says IEA.
Responding to the EU's actions to bail out Ireland, Professor Philip Booth, editorial and program director at the Institute of...
Read More >>
Editor's opinion: To EPC or not to EPC, that is the question.
The European Commission's public hearing today regarding drafting legislation setting migration end dates for SEPA instruments, may have...Read More >>
New deal for the euro exposes the currency as synthetic
Guest blogger, Bob Lyddon, managing director of the IBOS Banking Association, says alterations to the euro rules have merely served...
Read More >>
Basel III could jeopardise economic recovery
SMEs in emerging markets that rely on trade finance instruments rather than revolving bank loans will be worse off under the proposed Basel...Read More >>
Corporates will feel the full impact of the banking crisis when they refinance
Corporate insolvencies have been relatively low given the scale of the financial crisis, however Ann Cairns, former CEO of ABN AMRO...
Read More >>
Sibos Amsterdam: Banks need to learn to say no to investors
The financial services industry may face a "tsunami" of regulation, but regulation alone is not going to prevent another counterparty...
Read More >>
Sibos Amsterdam Innovation Keynote: The "Apple" of Banking
Will there ever been an "Apple" of Banking, a bank that is seen as being truly innovative and does not just think in terms of managing risk...
Read More >>
Pressure to set an end date for SEPA migration intensifies
ECB report stresses the need to properly address market participants' concerns about regulating a SEPA migration end date.
Read More >>
Sibos preview: Transaction banks expecting a more positive Sibos this year
A sombre mood has dominated the last two Sibos conferences as the financial services industry absorbed the consequences of increased...
Read More >>
EuroFinance Geneva - Corporates want SWIFT voting rights
"Bank-agnostic" platforms like SWIFT are being used by corporates to manage counterparty risk, but corporates are still not on the same...
Read More >>
BBA warns of risk of losing step with regulatory reform
The EU could be out of step with other countries as the appetite for globally coordinated regulatory reform appears to be waning, the BBA...
Read More >>
Systemically important banks likely to be worse off under Basel III capital rules
Commentators anticipate that "too big to fail" banks will have to hold more capital than the minimum required under the new rules and...
Read More >>
Capital punishment
Will the new capital ratios under Basel III constrain lending even further, and how much capital is enough capital if central banks and...
Read More >>
Many inside and outside of banking want to see the banking 'cartel' broken up
Michael Mainelli, director, Z/Yen Ltd says banks threatening to leave the UK is more about bonuses and taxes and not government threats...
Read More >>
Equens builds on its pan-European ambitions with German acquisition
Equens expands its footprint in Europe's largest card market, Germany, with the acquisition of montrada from Commerzbank.
Read More >>
Too big to fail?
As the Federal Reserve comes under pressure to disclose the details of those banks that sought financial assistance at the height of the...
Read More >>
Another data breach; another record fine
As another financial services provider is fined for not adequately protecting customer data, how can we expect the industry to make any...
Read More >>
LCH.Clearnet's future in doubt as an "independent"
With the London Stock Exchange's CEO, Xavier Rolet resigning from the Board of LCH.Clearnet, the writing is on the wall with respect to...
Read More >>
HSBC looks to Africa for growth
According to newspaper reports, HSBC is the front runner to buy a controlling stake in South Africa's fourth largest banking group by...
Read More >>
Book review: Senseless Panic - How Washington Failed America
It is refreshing to read a book that instead of pointing the finger at Wall Street and bank bonuses, highlights the role played by...
Read More >>
Transactions can be taxing
Financial-i's managing editor, Anita Hawser rants about a direct tax on financial transactions. Regulators may be rubbing...Read More >>